The present study describes the characteristics of the largest available series of patients with VT ablation for ES. These data showed that patients with ES are among the highest risk VT population with regard to recurrence and mortality. This is also the first study to evaluate the occurrence of comorbidities in a large cohort of patients with ES. Baseline and procedural characteristics are consistent with advanced substrates that present with ES. However, acute procedural success is associated with improved survival.
Patients with ES represent a relatively small portion of patient enrolled in large studies of VT ablation and most of the previously published data are single-center small series or case reports. ES is a challenging condition that occurs in ∼10%–28% of patients with an ICD,
1- Exner D.V.
- Pinski S.L.
- Wyse D.G.
- Renfroe E.G.
- Follmann D.
- Gold M.
- Beckman K.J.
- Coromilas J.
- Lancaster S.
- Hallstrom A.P.
Electrical storm presages nonsudden death: The Antiarrhythmics Versus Implantable Defibrillators (AVID) Trial.
, 2- Bansch D.
- Bocker D.
- Brunn J.
- Weber M.
- Breithardt G.
- Block M.
Clusters of ventricular tachycardias signify impaired survival in patients with idiopathic dilated cardiomyopathy and implantable cardioverter defibrillators.
, 3- Credner S.C.
- Klingenheben T.
- Mauss O.
- Sticherling C.
- Hohnloser S.H.
Electrical storm in patients with transvenous implantable cardioverter-defibrillators: incidence, management and prognostic implications.
and it was associated with a 3.15-fold increase in the risk of death.
7- Guerra F.
- Shkoza M.
- Scappini L.
- Flori M.
- Capucci A.
Role of electrical storm as a mortality and morbidity risk factor and its clinical predictors: a meta-analysis.
The high mortality may be related to the compound effects of the arrhythmia, the delivery of several ICD shock in a short time frame, and advanced heart failure; the relative contributions of these factors to mortality remains a matter of debate.
8- Nayyar S.
- Ganesan A.N.
- Brooks A.G.
- Sullivan T.
- Roberts-Thomson K.C.
- Sanders P.
Venturing into ventricular arrhythmia storm: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
It is well known that sudden death is tachyarrhythmia associated in two-thirds of the patients with an ICD.
9- Pires L.A.
- Lehmann M.H.
- Steinman R.T.
- Baga J.J.
- Schuger C.D.
Sudden death in implantable cardioverter-defibrillator recipients: clinical context, arrhythmic events and device responses.
ICD shocks may cause myocardial damage and are associated with increased mortality
10- Sweeney M.O.
- Sherfesee L.
- DeGroot P.J.
- Wathen M.S.
- Wilkoff B.L.
Differences in effects of electrical therapy type for ventricular arrhythmias on mortality in implantable cardioverter-defibrillator patients.
, 11- Larsen G.K.
- Evans J.
- Lambert W.E.
- Chen Y.
- Raitt M.H.
Shocks burden and increased mortality in implantable cardioverter-defibrillator patients.
, 12- Poole J.E.
- Johnson G.W.
- Hellkamp A.S.
- et al.
Prognostic importance of defibrillator shocks in patients with heart failure.
, 13- Mitchell L.B.
- Pineda E.A.
- Titus J.L.
- Bartosch P.M.
- Benditt D.G.
Sudden death in patients with implantable cardioverter defibrillators: the importance of post-shock electromechanical dissociation.
; these factors act on fragile patients, whom we identified to be older, with a lower LVEF, more advanced heart failure status, and more cardiovascular comorbidities, as compared with patients without ES. In this study, we showed that the 1-year survival of patients with ES is 61.3% if they continue to experience VT episodes after ablation and it was 88.7% when ablation was successful without VT recurrences. This might suggest that the arrhythmic episodes have a prominent detrimental effect on patient’s survival and that the adverse impact can be mitigated by a successful VT ablation procedure. However, survival of patients with ES and absence of VT recurrences was lower than that of patients without either ES and VT recurrences, suggesting that nonarrhythmic factors still act on these patients and might lead to death. It is possible that a comprehensive approach including not only the arrhythmia ablation but also careful treatment of the comorbidities that are more common in patients with ES, such as advanced heart failure, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, atrial fibrillation, diabetes, and chronic kidney disease, might have a positive effect on survival.
Timing of VT ablation
ES was the condition more frequently considered as the main indication for ablation in the survey by Dagres et al.
14- Dagres N.
- Varounis C.
- Flevari P.
- Piorkowski C.
- Bode K.
- Rallidis L.S.
- Tsougos E.
- Leftheriotis D.
- Sommer P.
- Hindricks G.
- Kremastinos D.T.
Mortality after catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation compared with antiarrhythmic drug therapy: a meta-analysis of randomized trials.
Several studies suggested that the outcome of ablation is better when performed earlier: in the study by Dinov et al,
15- Dinov B.
- Arya A.
- Bertagnolli L.
- Schirripa V.
- Schoene K.
- Sommer P.
- Bollmann A.
- Rolf S.
- Hindricks G.
Early referral for ablation of scar-related ventricular tachycardia is associated with improved acute and long-term outcomes: results from the Heart Center of Leipzig ventricular tachycardia registry.
VT recurred less frequently in the early ablation strategy (catheter ablation within 30 days after the first documented VT episode: 37.3%) as compared with later interventions (>60%); similar results were shown by Frankel et al,
16- Frankel D.S.
- Mountantonakis S.E.
- Robinson M.R.
- Zado E.S.
- Callans D.J.
- Marchlinski F.E.
Ventricular tachycardia ablation remains treatment of last resort in structural heart disease: argument for earlier intervention.
who classified patients as “late referrals” if they had ≥2 VT episodes, with the first and most recent episodes separated by ≥1 month. In the VTACH trial,
17- Kuck K.H.
- Schaumann A.
- Eckardt L.
- Willems S.
- Ventura R.
- Delacretaz E.
- Pitschner H.F.
- Kautzner J.
- Schumacher B.
- Hansen P.S.
Catheter ablation of stable ventricular tachycardia before defibrillator implantation in patients with coronary heart disease (VTACH): a multicentre randomised controlled trial.
early VT ablation before defibrillator implantation prolonged time to recurrence of VT; in the SMASH VT trial,
18- Reddy V.Y.
- Reynolds M.R.
- Neuzil P.
- Richardson A.W.
- Taborsky M.
- Jongnarangsin K.
- Kralovec S.
- Sediva L.
- Ruskin J.N.
- Josephson M.E.
Prophylactic catheter ablation for the prevention of defibrillator therapy.
an early ablation was associated with a reduction of ICD shocks afterward.
In our study, patients treated by ablation after ES were older than those without ES and more likely to have been previously treated with ≥1 antiarrhythmic drugs; the complexity of the procedure (more VTs inducible by PES before ablation, more radiofrequency delivery, more frequent hemodynamic support, and longer procedures times) and the mortality during the year after ablation were both higher in patients with ES. It appears, therefore, that ES is an event typical of the late phases in the history of patients with heart failure. It is conceivable that an ablation strategy in earlier phases of the patient’s history, before the occurrence of ES, might improve the quality of life and survival with lower technical procedure complexity; however, only randomized controlled trials could provide definitive conclusions on this issue.
19- Yokokawa M.
- Kim H.M.
- Baser K.
- et al.
Predictive value of programmed ventricular stimulation after catheter ablation of post-infarction ventricular tachycardia.
, 20- Kanjwal K.
- Imran N.
- Grubb B.
- Kanjwal Y.
Troponin elevation in patients with various tachycardias and normal epicardial coronaries.
End points for VT ablation in patients with ES
In the present multicenter experience, the abolition of the clinical VT, although associated with VT recurrence risk <30% during mid-term follow-up, had only a vague effect on survival; although harder to be obtained, the end point of absence of any inducible VT was associated with the highest (86.3%) survival rate. This confirms previous results in postinfarction patients by Yokokawa et al,
19- Yokokawa M.
- Kim H.M.
- Baser K.
- et al.
Predictive value of programmed ventricular stimulation after catheter ablation of post-infarction ventricular tachycardia.
who showed that absence of any VT inducibility postablation was independently associated with lower mortality.
Patients with ES undergoing VT ablation had an in-hospital mortality 4 times higher than that of patients without prior ES. The higher acute mortality is evident in patients with advanced heart failure, those requiring periprocedural hemodynamic support, and those undergoing epicardial procedures. It cannot be excluded that repeated arrhythmia inductions might negatively affect the already impaired myocardium.
20- Kanjwal K.
- Imran N.
- Grubb B.
- Kanjwal Y.
Troponin elevation in patients with various tachycardias and normal epicardial coronaries.
A strategy of substrate-based ablation can minimize the need for repetitive inductions of VT for mapping during ongoing arrhythmia.
6- Vergara P.
- Trevisi N.
- Ricco A.
- Petracca F.
- Baratto F.
- Cireddu M.
- Bisceglia C.
- Maccabelli G.
- Della Bella P.
Late potentials abolition as an additional technique for reduction of arrhythmia recurrence in scar related ventricular tachycardia ablation.
, 21- Di Biase L.
- Santangeli P.
- Burkhardt D.J.
- et al.
Endo-epicardial homogenization of the scar versus limited substrate ablation for the treatment of electrical storms in patients with ischemic cardiomyopathy.
, 22- Jais P.
- Maury P.
- Khairy P.
- et al.
Elimination of local abnormal ventricular activities: a new end point for substrate modification in patients with scar-related ventricular tachycardia.
, 23- Tzou W.S.
- Frankel D.S.
- Hegeman T.
- Supple G.E.
- Garcia F.C.
- Santangeli P.
- Katz D.F.
- Sauer W.H.
- Marchlinski F.E.
Core isolation of critical arrhythmia elements for treatment of multiple scar-based ventricular tachycardias.
, 24- Tung R.
- Mathuria N.S.
- Nagel R.
- Mandapati R.
- Buch E.F.
- Bradfield J.S.
- Vaseghi M.
- Boyle N.G.
- Shivkumar K.
Impact of local ablation on interconnected channels within ventricular scar: mechanistic implications for substrate modification.
In the VISTA trial,
25- Di Biase L.
- Burkhardt J.D.
- Lakkireddy D.
- et al.
Ablation of stable VTs versus substrate ablation in ischemic cardiomyopathy: the VISTA randomized multicenter trial.
substrate targeted ablation was associated with lower VT recurrence (15.5%) as compared with ablation of only the clinical VT (48.3%); the combined incidence of rehospitalization and mortality was also better with substrate targeted ablation.
Study limitations
The participating centers in the IVTCC are high-volume ablation hospitals that serve as state- or nationwide referrals for VT ablation procedures. As such, it is possible that there is a referral bias that may limit the generalizability of our results. The IVTCC database did not include detailed information about the ventricular substrate (voltage maps and magnetic resonance imaging scans) or severity of comorbidities, thus precluding further analysis on the correlation between the arrhythmic disease, stage of heart failure, severity of comorbidities, and outcomes. Because of the retrospective multicenter nature of this study, some clinical and procedural characteristics were not available for analysis. Antiarrhythmic drug therapy was left to the discretion of the treating physicians, and it could influence outcomes.